Is Too Much Being Built on Hilton Head Island?

by Loni Lueke

Is too much being built on Hilton Head Island? Will the island still stay green? Many people who live here ask themselves these questions right now. I understand that. So let me answer them, with the facts and with my honest view.

Yes, the island will stay green

At the end of October, the Town of Hilton Head Island and Beaufort County paid $18.2 million to protect about 18 acres. Because of these two deals, 211 homes can never be built there.

The bigger one is the old Adventure Hilton Head site on Broad Creek Marina Way, about 9.5 acres with the zip line and the go-kart track. The town and county bought it for $15.4 million. The town will clean up the site by the end of 2027 and is looking at public access later.

The second one is the Simmons Tract on Spanish Moss Road, 8.64 acres with old live oaks and a family cemetery. Here they paid $2.8 million for the development rights. The land stays with the Simmons family, and it stays undeveloped.

The county's Green Space Program has now protected about 53 acres on Hilton Head Island since 2024. That is about one million dollars an acre. For me, this is a clear sign that the island wants to protect what makes it special.

What is being built, and what it brings to residents

Northpoint on Jarvis Creek is 157 apartments next to the post office, on the north end of the island. Only people who physically work on Hilton Head Island can rent there, with rents from $1,600 to $3,600 a month. This helps the people who work on the island to also live here. The first residents should move in early 2027.

Novant Health plans a 25,000 square foot medical office on William Hilton Parkway, at the old Modern Classic Motors car dealership. They are planning services like urgent care, primary care, and physical therapy. For residents, this means good care closer to home. No opening date has been announced yet.

The Maidencane is a timeshare resort with 166 units off Folly Field Road, where the Port Royal Racquet Club used to be. Construction is already underway. I know many residents do not want more timeshares on the island, and I understand that. But it also gives visitors a chance to explore Hilton Head Island and to get to know it better.

Two rental projects are still in review. The Broad Creek Apartments, 254 units off Marshland Road, would replace an old condo building that was never finished. Driftwood, 58 townhomes next to Indigo Run, is near a bird rookery, and many neighbors are worried about the birds. Both still need approval from the town.

Can you still find a home on the island?

Yes. New homes are still being built. Many older homes in the gated communities are remodeled and come back on the market. So there are still options for people who want to live on Hilton Head Island. It may take some time to find the right house, and patience pays off.

If you do not want to wait, there are good alternatives close by. Bluffton and Hardeeville have a lot of new construction, and nowadays more and more people look at Beaufort too.

My honest answer

Is too much being built on Hilton Head Island? In my view, no. The island is changing, but it is growing carefully. It is protecting land, it is creating homes for the people who work here, and it is bringing better medical care closer to residents. I am optimistic, and I will keep watching these projects and share when something changes.

Warm regards,
Loni Lueke
The German Realtor, eXp Realty Luxury

If you are looking for a home on Hilton Head Island, in Bluffton, or in Beaufort, or you want to know what these changes mean for your home, reach out anytime.

Connect with me

This article was created with the help of AI and reviewed by Loni Lueke, The German Realtor.

Loni Lueke
Loni Lueke

Agent License ID: SC: 95662

+1(843) 505-1193 | luekeloni@gmail.com

GET MORE INFORMATION

Name
Phone*
Message